Loan vs Investment
Why invest wins here
Related calculators
The math, simply
You have a lump sum. You can either prepay your loan (saving future interest) or invest it (earning future returns). The winner depends on:
- Loan interest rate — a guaranteed "return" if you prepay.
- After-tax investment return — uncertain but often higher for equities.
- Time horizon — longer horizons favour investing (compounding + risk premium).
- Risk tolerance — prepaying is risk-free; investing is not.
Frequently asked questions
Should I always prepay high-interest loans first?
Yes — credit card debt (36-42%) and personal loans (12-24%) almost always warrant prepayment before investing. Returns rarely beat those rates reliably.
What about home loan tax benefits?
Home loan principal (₹1.5L under 80C) and interest (₹2L under Section 24) give deductions. This effectively lowers your loan rate — factor it in before prepaying.
Is a 12% investment return guaranteed?
No. Equity returns are volatile. Over 7-10 years they've averaged 11-13% in India, but short-term can be negative. Use conservative assumptions.
What is the safest approach?
Build an emergency fund first, then prepay any loan above 11%, then invest surplus in a mix of equity and debt matching your goals.
Why does tax matter here?
Investment gains are taxed (LTCG 12.5% on equity over ₹1.25L, slab rate on debt). This reduces your effective return, sometimes flipping the decision toward prepayment.